In the real estate market, transparency is the value that protects both the seller and the buyer. Often, when you decide to list a property or find the home of your dreams, you run into a complex bureaucratic reality: urban planning discrepancies.
Many owners are convinced that an updated cadastral floor plan is equivalent to a house being "fully compliant." However, the technical reality goes much deeper. In this article, the Domus Sicilia team will clarify how to manage irregularities without compromising the sale.
1. The Fundamental Distinction: "As-Built" State vs. Building Permits
The first step toward a secure sale is understanding that a property’s legality is based on a comparison between the current state of the home and the project filed with the Municipality (Comune).
-
Cadastral Compliance: This concerns the fiscal/tax aspect. While the floor plan at the Cadastre (Land Registry) must match reality, this alone does not guarantee building legality.
-
Urban Planning Compliance: This is the property’s true "pedigree." it is confirmed by verifying the building permits (Licenze, Concessioni, Permessi di Costruire, SCIA, or CILA) filed in the municipal archives.
In front of a notary, the validity of the deed depends on urban planning truth, not just cadastral records.
2. What Are the Most Common Discrepancies?
Irregularities are not all the same and generally fall into three categories:
-
Minor Discrepancies: Small shifts in internal partition walls, a different layout of spaces, or relocated doors. These are usually resolved through a regularization procedure (CILA in sanatoria) and the payment of a fixed fine.
-
Essential Variations: Changes that alter the building's footprint, volume, or intended use (e.g., converting a technical room into a living space). These require a deep technical analysis to verify if they can be legalized.
-
Non-Remediable Violations: Works carried out in total absence of permits or in conflict with landscape restrictions and master plans. In these cases, a sale may be legally impossible.
3. The Mortgage Obstacle
For the buyer, a building violation is not just a legal problem, but a financial one. The bank appraiser (perito) is tasked with verifying that the approved project matches the property. If un-regularized discrepancies are found, the mortgage approval will be blocked, effectively halting the negotiation.
4. Who Is Responsible for Regularization?
According to law and standard practice, a property must be transferred "free of encumbrances, charges, and defects." Therefore, regularization is the Seller’s responsibility, who must bear the costs of technical fees and administrative fines.
While parties can agree otherwise, it is essential that any agreement is clear, written, and supported by a technical opinion confirming that the violation is actually "sanabile" (capable of being legalized).
5. The Domus Sicilia Method: Prevention is Better than Cure
Our goal is to prevent a deal from collapsing just days before the closing. For this reason, our protocol includes:
-
Preventive Document Check-up: We analyze building permits even before advertising the property.
-
Expert Collaboration: We work with qualified technicians to evaluate the costs and timelines of any necessary regularizations.
-
Protection for All Parties: We ensure the buyer purchases with full awareness and the seller reaches the deed without the risk of future damage claims.
Addressing building violations requires expertise and honesty. It shouldn't be a source of fear, but a process to be managed with extreme professionalism.
Add comment
Comments